Notarial Conciliation: Real Cases and Advantages of Notarial Conciliation

Two practical examples of dispute resolution through notarial conciliation.

In this article, we explain:

Notarial Conciliation: Real Cases and Advantages of Notarial Conciliation

Introduction

On October 7, 2026, the Notarial Association of Catalonia held one of its Webinot sessions entitled “Notarial Conciliation in Practice: Analysis of Contractual and Inheritance Cases”, featuring Barcelona notaries Antonio Bosch Carrera and Javier Monedero Alcover.

The session focused on examining, from a practical perspective, the opportunities offered by notarial conciliation to resolve disputes without having to go to court.

Drawing on two real cases, one involving a contractual dispute and the other an inheritance dispute, the speakers explained the difficulties that may arise during conciliation proceedings, the techniques used to bring the parties' positions closer together, and the legal solutions that enabled them to reach an agreement.

What is notarial conciliation?

Notarial conciliation is a procedure through which two or more parties involved in a dispute attempt to reach an agreement with the assistance of a notary.

It is regulated by Articles 81 to 83 of the Notarial Act and allows disputes of a contractual, commercial, inheritance or family nature to be addressed, provided they concern matters over which the parties may freely dispose.

In this procedure, the notary acts impartially, facilitates dialogue and helps the parties identify possible solutions. Their involvement can be particularly useful when negotiations have reached a deadlock or when there are significant differences in the legal assessment of the opposing parties' positions.

Conciliation is characterised by its voluntary nature, confidentiality and flexibility. The parties retain the right to decide whether they wish to reach an agreement and on what terms, while the notary ensures that the agreed solution complies with the law.

A contractual dispute: a legally binding contract or mere negotiations?

The first case, presented by Barcelona notary Javier Monedero Alcover, concerned a dispute that arose during the negotiation of a high-value real estate transaction.

The main issue was to determine whether the parties had already reached an agreement on the essential terms of the contract, meaning that the sale and purchase agreement should be considered legally binding, or whether they were still at the preliminary negotiation stage.

The parties' legal positions were very different, and negotiations had reached a deadlock.

During the conciliation proceedings, joint and individual meetings were held, some of them remotely, allowing the parties' positions to be examined and the consequences of pursuing legal proceedings to be assessed.

One of the tools used was the analysis of the Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement (BATNA), which allows the realistic prospects of achieving a satisfactory outcome through negotiation to be compared with other alternatives, particularly legal proceedings.

The notary's intervention helped bring the dispute back on track and enabled the parties to reach an agreement, which was ultimately formalised through the execution of the public deed of sale and purchase.

The case also provided an opportunity to reflect on certain practical aspects of the procedure, such as the importance of the notary's impartiality, the effectiveness of notifications and the need to adapt the conciliation process to the specific circumstances of each dispute.

An inheritance dispute: a claim for a compulsory share of the estate

The second case, presented by Barcelona notary Antonio Bosch Carrera, addressed an inheritance dispute involving a claim to compulsory inheritance rights and various property-related issues arising from a death.

The legal disagreements were compounded by a particularly delicate family situation, marked by considerable emotional tension and deep mistrust between the parties.

The notary's intervention made it possible to organise the various claims, examine their legal grounds and provide a forum for negotiation in which the parties concerned could consider possible solutions.

One of the most interesting aspects was the use of a notarial deposit as a means of facilitating compliance with the agreement. This arrangement provided safeguards for the parties and helped overcome some of the difficulties that had prevented the negotiations from being concluded.

Finally, the proceedings concluded with an amicable settlement that resolved the matters in dispute.

This case demonstrated that, in certain inheritance disputes, the difficulties in reaching an agreement do not arise exclusively from legal or financial differences. Personal and family relationships can play a significant role, requiring particular attention during the conciliation proceedings.

What are the advantages of notarial conciliation?

The two cases presented during the session illustrate some of the advantages of notarial conciliation compared with court proceedings.

Firstly, it offers the parties the opportunity to participate directly in finding a solution while retaining control over the terms of any agreement reached.

The procedure also allows greater flexibility in organising meetings, which can be held in person or remotely, and facilitates the search for solutions tailored to the circumstances of the dispute.

Another advantage is the involvement of a legal professional who, acting impartially, can help identify the legal issues hindering negotiations and verify the legality of the agreement reached.

The legal enforceability of the agreement is particularly important.

Pursuant to Article 83 of the Notarial Act, the public deed formalising the conciliation is enforceable under the terms established by law. This allows the parties to seek direct judicial enforcement if either party fails to fulfil their obligations and the applicable legal requirements are met.

Finally, conciliation can avoid the costs, delays and uncertainty associated with court proceedings, although its outcome always depends on the willingness of the parties to reach an agreement.

The experience gained from the two cases discussed during the session demonstrates that, even when the initial positions seem difficult to reconcile, well-managed negotiations can lead to satisfactory solutions for those involved.

Notarial conciliation 

Can Contact with our team and we will guide you through the entire process:

👉 LinkedIn
👉 Instagram

 

Request information

Call us, visit us, or fill out the contact form. 

Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday from 9:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. and from 3:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.
Saturday and Sunday: Closed.